What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives regarding the war in Ukraine?
This question has generated widespread interest following several latest rounds of ceasefire talks, which until now appeared to yield little fruit four years since the full-scale invasion.
Another phase of American-facilitated negotiations is expected to occur in the Swiss city in the coming days. Ahead of it, an important member of the Ukrainian leadership's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in the latest direct military discussions, has provided his viewpoint.
According to the negotiator, these interactions are business-like and generally devoid of the type of political and historical grandstanding observed in other forums by Russian leadership.
"The military have a superior understanding of what is going on in the battlefield," he stated in a meeting earlier this week.
"It's another thing if they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of relaying information directly…without altering or changing the information," he continued.
It is far from an simple thing to attempt to end a major conflict. The nature of the front line in eastern Ukraine - where tens of thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles operate and strike over a vast so-called "grey zone" between the two sides, while two hundred thousand Ukrainian residents still live in the "heavily fortified" urban areas of the eastern region - renders the technical business of separation extremely complicated.
"You have to establish a clear set of rules and procedures," Kyslytsya explained, "along with a way to confirm and monitor."
The Involvement of External Parties
Much of these preparations, he said, is complete, thanks in part to the direct involvement of US representatives, including General Alexus Grynkewich and Dan Driscoll.
It's obviously against Ukraine's interest to disparage envoys of the current US government, but when he compliments the US delegation for its work, he comes across as genuine.
"We must credit the Americans for their dedication and their patience," he states, "because they sit in the sessions continuously. They not only observe…they ask questions and they listen to our answers."
Kyslytsya was equally complimentary about the contributions of Donald Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner, whom he referred to as "experienced", and billionaire mediator Steve Witkoff, whom he described as "a much wiser individual than the caricature portrayal you see in the press".
The United States, Kyslytsya said, will undertake a key role in overseeing any potential ceasefire, with resources encompassing satellite and other types of high-tech monitoring.
"We need someone who will serve as adjudication, because if there is a violation there should be a third party that is reliable [and] authoritative."
Previous and Present Monitoring Challenges
During an eight-year period before the major invasion in 2022, this monitoring role was played by the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe - a body whose restricted means and lack of punitive powers rendered it largely incapable of preventing an escalation.
"It was quite an achievement [for them] just to have two drones flying over the area," Kyslytsya commented. "It's kind of the stone age period compared to what we are dealing with now."
In comparison, recent reports suggest that as many as 12,000 drones are active over the urban center of a frontline city at any one time.
A Personal Account on Facing the Adversary
Inquired about his ability to sit across the table from delegates from a head of state in the Russian government who has shown readiness to expend more than a million of his country's soldiers to subjugate Ukraine, the diplomat, with extensive UN experience, offered his answer.
He explained that he'd had a long time of experience.
"I witnessed far more difficult situations. I spent a five-year term in New York, three of them prior to the full-scale invasion. I regularly had to sit in the room with the enemy on a frequent basis."
One evening is seared in his recollection: 23 February 2022.
During an emergency Security Council meeting, called to discuss the urgent crisis in Ukraine, the ambassador received news that his country was being assaulted.
At the same time, seven time zones to the east in the capital, the first far-off explosions were heard as the all-out attack on Ukraine commenced.
Amid moments of intense drama, the ambassador attempted to get Russia's ambassador, the Russian envoy, to call his superior, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain guarantees that Russian troops would not invade.
"I've already said everything that I am aware of today," Nebenzia replied, as recalled by Kyslytsya. "I'm not going to disturb Minister Lavrov at this hour."
The world changed at that moment. The diplomat stayed at the United Nations for another three years prior to returning to Kyiv.
The Path Ahead
Should the negotiating teams meet again in Geneva on Thursday, he will participate, still working through the contours and logistics of a halt in fighting but anticipating continuously for the most important element of the puzzle to fall into place.
"Hostilities could be ended by simply one call of an individual to his military chief of staff," he stated.
"But apparently, the Kremlin dictator [Vladimir Putin] is not up to stopping the war at present."